Aadhaar Birth Date Proof : The Delhi High Court has delivered an important ruling on Aadhaar cards, clarifying that Aadhaar is not conclusive proof of date of birth. According to the court, Aadhaar is meant to establish a person's identity, but the date of birth mentioned on it cannot be treated as final proof of age. The ruling could also affect cases where employees' retirement ages are determined based on the date of birth recorded in Aadhaar.

Company Removed Employee Based on Aadhaar
The case involves JJ Electronics and its employee, Rozamma Joy. Joy worked as a Finishing Man at the company. Her Aadhaar card mentioned her birth year as 1959, while her ESIC records listed her date of birth as May 20, 1960. The company considered the birth year recorded in Aadhaar to be correct and terminated her employment on the grounds that she had completed 58 years of age. The employee challenged the decision, and the matter reached the Labour Court.

Labour Court Ruled in Employee’s Favour
Rozamma Joy filed a complaint before the Labour Court challenging her termination. She sought reinstatement along with pending wages and other benefits. The Labour Court refused to treat the date of birth recorded in Aadhaar as conclusive and accepted the date mentioned in her ESIC records. It directed the company to pay her outstanding wages and other applicable benefits. The company subsequently challenged the decision before the Delhi High Court.

What High Court Said About Aadhaar
In its order dated November 13, Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri dismissed JJ Electronics' petition. The court observed that under the Aadhaar law, the card serves as proof of identity, not definitive proof of date of birth. It also referred to UIDAI's 2018 instructions, which state that the date of birth in Aadhaar may be recorded based on documents or information provided by the applicant. Therefore, the birth year mentioned in Aadhaar alone cannot be treated as the final truth.

Company Must Pay Pending Wages
The High Court held that Rozamma Joy had not reached the retirement age in 2017. The company could not terminate her services solely on the basis of the birth year recorded in Aadhaar. The court also found that the necessary provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act had not been followed at the time of her termination. Consequently, her dismissal was considered illegal, and the Labour Court's order directing payment of pending wages and benefits was upheld.